My Top 3 Cookie Spots in Toronto
Toronto is known for its incredible food scene, and when it comes to cookies, this city doesn’t disappoint. Whether you’re searching for the perfect mid-day snack, a post-lunch pick-me-up, or simply a sweet treat to indulge in, the cookie options in Toronto are endless. To make it easier for you, I’ve narrowed down my favorite cookie spots in Toronto—each with its own distinct style, flavor, and irresistible charm
1. Andrea’s Cookies – Soft, Gooey Perfection
If you’re a cookie lover, Andrea’s Cookies is a must-try. Situated in the heart of Toronto, Andrea’s is famous for crafting some of the softest, most gooey cookies in the city. Their signature jumbo cookies feature crispy edges and a soft, chewy center that will transport you back to homemade cookies with a gourmet twist.
Their popular cookie, “The OG,” is loaded with rich, melty chocolate chips—perfect for chocolate lovers! Andrea’s also offers creative flavors like peanut butter stuffed cookies and seasonal specials such as pumpkin spice and red velvet. Feeling extra indulgent? Try their delicious cookie sandwiches, which are as decadent as they sound.
Why I Love It: The texture of Andrea’s cookies is always on point, and their unique flavors keep me coming back.
Pro Tip: Pre-order for guaranteed availability.
Link: Andrea’s Cookies
2. La Gourmand – Massive, Chewy & Packed with Flavor
La Gourmand is not just a cozy café in Toronto—it’s home to some of the best cookies in the city. Located on Spadina Avenue, this charming spot is perfect for grabbing a coffee and enjoying one of their giant, freshly baked cookies. Known for their thick, chewy texture, La Gourmand’s cookies are big enough to share, but trust me, you won’t want to!
Their chocolate chunk cookie is my go-to. The large chunks of premium chocolate make each bite feel like a luxurious treat. For nut lovers, their pecan cookies provide a satisfying crunch that perfectly balances the cookie’s chewy goodness.
Why I Love It: La Gourmand’s cookies strike the perfect balance between crispy edges and a soft center—cookie heaven!
Link: La Gourmand
3. Night Baker – Creative Cookies with Surprise Fillings
For a truly unique cookie experience, Night Baker is my go-to spot. Known for their “almost too pretty to eat” cookies, each treat at Night Baker is a delightful surprise. These gourmet cookies often come with special fillings like molten chocolate, cheesecake swirls, or gooey caramel. Their bestseller, the “O.G. Original Gooey,” is a crowd favorite, featuring a perfectly gooey center and a crisp exterior.
For those seeking something out of the ordinary, Night Baker also offers adventurous flavors such as matcha and earl grey cookies. Whether you’re into classic or creative cookies, this spot will satisfy your sweet tooth.
Why I Love It: Night Baker’s cookies are like mini works of art, with unique fillings that make every bite exciting.
Link: Night Baker
Whether you’re craving a classic chocolate chip cookie or something more adventurous, these three Toronto cookie spots are bound to impress. Each place has its own distinct vibe, making them perfect for repeat visits. So, next time you find yourself in Toronto and need a cookie fix, be sure to stop by one (or all!) of these amazing bakeries.
What’s your favorite cookie spot in Toronto? Let me know in the comments!
Discover more from herTOdays
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.